About one-third of patients with chronic hepatitis B maintained a profile consistent with inactive disease 1 year after withdrawal from treatment in the randomized HBRN trial , which compared tenofovir with and without pegylated interferon (PEG-IFN). The two treatment groups, however, had similarly low rates of hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) loss, the trial’s primary end point.
The successful withdrawals could inform discussions with patients who are “very motivated to have a finite treatment course,” said investigator Norah Terrault, MD, from the University of Southern California, Los Angeles. The results might “help patients in talking about expectations,” she said, because “there’s a one in three chance they won’t go back on treatment” if they meet specific metrics.
In HBRN, the metrics for withdrawal from treatment after 192 weeks included low levels of viral DNA (<1,000 IU/mL) for at least 24 weeks, no cirrhosis, negative week 144 test results for the hepatitis B envelope antigen (HBeAg), and week 180 conversion to anti-HBe positivity.
Of 102 patients who received tenofovir monotherapy for 192 weeks and who completed the trial, 51 met these criteria. After withdrawal from treatment, 30% still had DNA levels below 1,000 IU/mL and normal ALT at week 240, which is consistent with inactive chronic hepatitis B.
Of the 99 participants in the combination group – who received PEG-IFN for the first 24 of 192 weeks in addition to tenofovir – 60 met the withdrawal criteria at 192 weeks. At week 240, 39% of this withdrawal group still had DNA and ALT values consistent with inactive disease.
Rates of HBsAg loss, which signals functional cure, were low in the two groups, however. At week 240, fewer patients in the tenofovir monotherapy group tested negative for HBsAg than in the tenofovir plus PEG-IFN combination group, but the difference was not significant (4.5% vs. 5.7%).
The timing of HBsAg loss differed between the groups. In the combination group, the loss largely occurred before treatment withdrawal, likely because of the antiviral effects of interferon, Dr. Terrault said in an interview. In the monotherapy group, the loss occurred after 192 weeks, possibly reflecting the immunologic consequences of treatment withdrawal.
The timing of ALT flares also differed between groups. In the combination group, 58% of flares occurred during the 24-week PEG-IFN period. In the monotherapy group, 70% of flares occurred after tenofovir was stopped at 192 weeks.
The flare picture is a tricky one, said Dr. Terrault. The episodes might be a positive factor in HBsAg loss, but severe flares carry a risk for decompensation. Good predictors of the severity of flares are lacking, and “that is the hurdle” to finding a balance with these trade-offs.
‘Partially a failure and partially a success’
The findings are “partially a failure and partially a success,” said Robert Gish, MD, from Loma Linda (Calif.) University of Health, who was not involved in the study.
The low rates of HBsAg loss and the similarity between the two treatment groups represent the failure, he explained. The success is for the patients who were HBeAg-positive when the study began because they had high HBeAg loss rates in both the monotherapy and combination groups (41% vs. 61%; P = .06).