According to the World Health Organization (WHO), approximately 5% of adults (or 280 million people) suffer from depression globally. Although depression is more common in women, it can affect anyone. It is seen in all socioeconomic classes, ages, and races. In response, the WHO developed the Mental Health Gap Action Programme to bring mental health care services to those in need.
Depression can lead to severe consequences, such as loss of employment, relationships difficulties, and suicide. In fact, suicide is the 10th leading cause of death in the United States.
Dr. Linda Girgis
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF), in past years, concluded that there was insufficient evidence to screen adolescents and adults for depression, However, new guidelines were issued this year in which the task force concluded there was a moderate benefit to screening adults for depression but insufficient evidence to screen for suicide risk. The agency now recommends screening for depression in all adults, even in the absence of risk factors, by using brief screening instruments such as the PHQ (Patient Health Questionnaire).
As family doctors, we have witnessed the burden of depression in our practices. The previous recommendations neglected the fact that mental health disorders were often purposely hidden because of stigma. Many patients do not readily come for treatment for mental illness and sometimes do not even accept these diagnoses. It is good that screening is now recommended, but we need to do more to tear down the stigma attached to mental illness.
These new guidelines do not address the effect that the lack of available mental health services has on treatment. It can take months to get an appointment for a patient with a mental health disorder, even if that person is potentially suicidal. Primary care physicians are often left treating these disorders; sometimes we are treating mental illness whether we feel comfortable doing so or not. Patients may not receive the best care but it is better than no care at all.
Although treating anxiety and depression is common for primary care doctors, specialists should be contacted when cases get more complicated. Even a call to crisis intervention can lead to an emergency department visit with discharge back to the family doctor because there is nowhere else to send the patient. The burden falls on us when we are already burdened by many other things, such as the rising rates of obesity with the resultant consequences of diabetes and heart disease. We simply do not have the time or expertise to treat complicated mental illness.
Creating guidelines to diagnose more undetected cases of depression without increasing the infrastructure to handle it is only going to lead to more pressure on family doctors. Many of us are already burnt out and at our limits. Yes, we want to diagnose every case of depression we can and to treat these patients for these disorders, but we need help.
Another problem with the guidelines is the recommendation to screen for depression and not suicide risk. As family doctors, we ask all patients who are depressed if they have thoughts of hurting themselves or others. Also, some people who commit suicide are not clinically depressed. These questions are simple to ask on an intake form.
Screening for depression is a pretty simple process. A patient can complete a screening tool or the clinician can directly ask the questions. It is a quick, noninvasive process. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders criteria for diagnosing depression are pretty rigid and straightforward so misdiagnoses are not likely to be common.
The new guidelines do not make recommendations for treatment. In the real world, we often see patients unable to get the medications we prescribe because their insurance won’t cover it. Having guidelines supporting medication use would be very helpful.
In the area where I practice, it is difficult to refer a patient for counseling despite there being a plethora of counselors, therapists, and psychologists. These mental health providers often take only cash-paying patients, which eliminates access for many patients.
If we truly want to address the ever-increasing rates of depression in our country, we need to do much more than create new screening guidelines (screening that many family doctors were already doing). We must remove stigma, especially in the health care setting, fund mental health services, make them more readily available, and provide care that is affordable and covered by insurance. Until then, we are just going to add to the load of family doctors until we either break or leave our profession. Patients deserve better.
Dr. Girgis practices family medicine in South River, N.J., and is a clinical assistant professor of family medicine at Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, New Brunswick, N.J. She was paid by Pfizer as a consultant on Paxlovid and is the editor in chief of Physician’s Weekly.