Discussion
This retrospective chart review study found that LOS was shorter in patients with AWS treated with g/b compared with those treated with benzodiazepines, with no significant difference in safety outcomes such as seizures, DTs, or intensive care unit transfers. Although there was a statistically significant difference in the primary outcome between the 2 groups, it appears that patients on benzodiazepine therapy originally had more severe AWS presentation as their admission and maximum CIWA scores were statistically significantly higher compared with the g/b group. Thus, patients who were initially started on g/b had less serious AWS presentations. Based on this information we can conclude that the g/b combination may be an effective option for mild AWS management.
To our knowledge, this is the first study that has investigated the combination of g/b compared with benzodiazepines for AWS management in hospitalized patients. The research design of this project was adapted from the Bates and colleagues study that examined gabapentin monotherapy use for the treatment of patients hospitalized with AWS.9 We specifically used the primary outcome that they defined in their study since their LOS definition aimed to reflect clinically active withdrawal rather than simply hours of hospitalization, which would decrease the risk of confounding the primary outcome. The results of our research were similar to Bates and colleagues as they found that the gabapentin protocol appeared to be an effective and safe option compared with benzodiazepines for patients hospitalized with AWS.9
Limitations
This study has multiple limitations. As it was a retrospective chart review study, the data collection accuracy depends on accurate recordkeeping. Additionally, certain information was missing, such as CIWA scores for some patients. This study has limited external validity as most of the patients were older, White, and male, and the data collection was limited only to a single center. Therefore, it is uncertain whether the results of this study can be generalized to other populations. Also, this study had a small sample size, and we were not able to obtain the intended number of patients to achieve a power of 80%. Lastly, some background characteristics, such as admission and maximum CIWA scores, were not distributed equally between groups. Therefore, future studies are needed with a larger sample size that examine the LOS in the g/b group compared with the benzodiazepine group and in which CIWA scores are matched to reduce the effect of extraneous variables.
Conclusions
Gabapentin and baclofen combination seems to be an effective and safe alternative to benzodiazepines and may be considered for managing mild AWS in hospitalized patients, but additional research is needed to examine this regimen.
Acknowledgments
Research committee: Hong-Yen Vi, PharmD, BCPS; Shaiza Khan, PharmD, BCPS; Yinka Alaka, PharmD; Jennifer Kwon, PharmD, BCOP. Co-investigators: Zachary Rosenfeldt, PharmD, BCPS; Kaylee Caniff, PharmD, BCIDP.